Editorial illustration
The Trump administration made the right call this week when it removed former Miss California USA winner Carrie Prejean Boller from the White House Religious Liberty Commission after she reportedly attempted to derail a hearing on antisemitism in the United States. Texas Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, who chairs the commission, said Prejean Boller tried to “hijack” the proceedings to advance her own personal and political agenda, turning what should have been a serious examination of rising Jew-hatred into a platform for grievance. What followed was even more revealing than the incident itself — a bitter, public meltdown in which Prejean Boller turned her fire directly on President Trump and accused the commission of being controlled by a “Zionist political framework,” as detailed in her open letter posted on X (formerly Twitter).
And while Prejean Boller used her position to praise the Council on American-Islamic Relations, declare that “Catholics don’t embrace Zionism,” and accuse the administration of serving foreign interests and “betraying the MAGA movement,” these claims were based on statements she made in that same letter. That is not principled dissent. It is someone who confused a seat at the table with a license to burn the table down, and the swiftness of her removal suggests the White House understood exactly what it was dealing with.
Religious liberty in America is not a game. It is the foundational freedom upon which every other right depends, enshrined in the very first words of the First Amendment. The commission exists to protect that liberty for Christians, Jews, Muslims, and every faith tradition that calls this nation home. When antisemitism is the subject — and it urgently should be, given the wave of attacks on Jewish communities from Michigan synagogues to college campuses as reported by the Anti-Defamation League — the last thing the proceedings need is someone steering the conversation toward personal vendettas dressed up in theological language.
Prejean Boller’s open letter to the President was a masterclass in missing the point. She cast herself as a martyr for Catholic values, claimed she was the victim of a “witch hunt,” and insisted that her removal violated her own religious freedom. But here is the thing about serving on a presidential commission: it is a privilege, not a right, and it comes with the expectation that you advance the mission, not yourself. Multiple religious leaders and conservatives praised her ouster, with one former Trump White House official telling Fox News that “these commissions exist to advance the President’s agenda, not to serve as a personal Jew-hating platform.”
There is a broader lesson here for the conservative movement, and it is one worth stating plainly. You can be a faithful Catholic and support Israel’s right to exist. You can critique specific Israeli policies without veering into the swamp of antisemitic conspiracy theories. You can advocate for religious liberty without turning it into a weapon against another faith community. The overwhelming majority of Christians in the MAGA movement understand this instinctively, which is precisely why Prejean Boller’s antics were met with near-universal condemnation from the right, as noted in reports from conservative outlets like Breitbart.
President Trump built a coalition that includes devout Catholics, evangelical Protestants, Orthodox Jews, and people of good faith from every tradition. That coalition holds together because it is grounded in shared principles — life, liberty, family, and the conviction that America’s strength comes from its moral foundation. Anyone who tries to fracture that coalition by pitting faiths against each other is doing the left’s work for them, whether they realize it or not. The commission will be stronger without her, and the cause of religious liberty in America will be better served by people who understand that defending one group’s freedom does not require attacking another’s. Providence watches over the bold.
About The Author
