Former Senator Joe Manchin didn’t mince words when asked Sunday whether he could ever support a socialist candidate for office. “No way,” the West Virginia Democrat-turned-independent told CBS’s Face the Nation. “My God, no.” It was the kind of blunt rejection that has become rare in a Democratic Party increasingly uncomfortable with drawing ideological lines, and it came with a warning that should make party leaders pause before embracing the far-left flank that has been gaining ground in primaries across the country.
When host Margaret Brennan pressed him on whether he might support socialist candidates who have “some good ideas,” Manchin pushed back with the exasperated tone of a man who has watched his party drift into territory he barely recognizes. “I support the good ideas,” he said. “But how could you support some of the crazy stuff they’re for?” The question hangs in the air for anyone paying attention to Democratic Socialist platforms that include dismantling the Senate, abolishing police departments, and eliminating the energy production that powers the American economy.
Manchin laid out the stakes with characteristic directness. “Have you seen their platform? They’re for dismantling everything that we know, whether it be the structure of government, Congress itself, or the Senate they want to get rid of, and then they start talking about all the crazy things, no police, no this, no this, no that. Are you crazy?” The former senator’s daughter, Heather Manchin, who appeared alongside him, added her own critique that cuts to the heart of the Democratic Party’s current predicament. “Control has now completely outweighed character,” she said. “If you’re more interested in control, and that’s all that matters, your vote count, versus the character of the person and the platform they’re running on, I think we’re living with the consequences of that.”
The timing of these comments matters. Several openly socialist candidates backed by the Democratic Socialists of America have won Democratic primaries this year, including New York City mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani and congressional hopeful Darializa Avila Chevalier, according to primary results reported by major outlets. A July Fox News poll found that more Democrats now view socialism favorably than capitalism, with 52 percent holding positive views of the former versus 41 percent for the latter. Among all registered voters, 30 percent view socialism favorably, up from 27 percent last year. These numbers represent a fundamental shift in how a significant portion of the Democratic base views the American economic system, and Manchin’s rejection of that shift puts him firmly at odds with the party’s ascendant progressive wing.
What makes Manchin’s stance particularly notable is his emphasis on issues that used to be consensus Democratic positions. “We want a crime-free area,” he continued. “We have to have police for that. Yeah. We want a strong defense, we want a strong border. But if Democrats can’t say that, and they start lining up with the socialist demands of what you are to be a socialist, energy will be gone. There’ll be no energy, OK? We have right now a tremendous amount of energy we’re producing, and the world depends more on us than ever before.” This is the voice of a Democrat from an earlier era, one who understood that working-class voters care more about safe streets and affordable gas than ideological purity tests.
Manchin’s break with his party’s leftward drift reflects a broader tension that will shape the midterm elections and beyond. The Democratic establishment has been reluctant to confront its socialist wing, perhaps calculating that the energy and enthusiasm of young progressive activists outweighs the risks of alienating moderate voters. But Manchin’s warning suggests this calculation may be catastrophically wrong. When a former Democratic senator feels compelled to go on national television and declare that his party has lost its mind, it signals a rupture that cannot be papered over with messaging memos or unity tours. Providence watches over the bold.
About The Author
